The Reserve at Petoskey

501 W Mitchell St, Petoskey, MI 49770

  • For Sale $750,000
  • Property Type Retail - Street Retail
  • Property Size 6,496 SF
  • Units 5
  • Lot Size 0.5 Acre
  • Property Tenancy Multi-Tenant
  • Year Built 1970
  • Date Updated Jul 30, 2025
er.
Want more info on this listing?

Reach out to the broker for more info on lease terms and amenities

Highlights

  • A?uent, Year-Round Market – Located in a stable, high-income resort community with strong seasonal tourism to boost business
  • Brand New Regional Lease – New 5-year lease with Cottage Inn Pizza, a trusted regional franchise with decades of brand recognition and a loyal customer base; long-term occupancy history supports stable, reliable income
  • Comprehensive Build-out & Upgraded Systems – Cottage Inn will be doing an extensive interior build-out, but also an upgrade in all electrical and HVAC systems to the building to ensure modern functionality and reduce maintenance costs
  • Cottage Inn Pizza Sets Goal is to Reach 100 Stores within 12 months!
  • Excellent Access & Parking – Easy ingress/egress with on-site parking; minutes from downtown, major retailers, and area amenities
  • Existing Tenants Occupied the Property 14, 12 and 4 years, Respectively
  • Flexible Commercial Use – Con?gured for retail, o?ce, medical, or service users; adaptable layout supports a wide range of businesses
  • Healthcare-Adjacent Location – Directly across from McLaren Northern Michigan Hospital (400+ beds), ideal for medical or service-oriented tenants
  • New Roof Unit 1 and 2 ($34,000) and Parking Lot Seal and Stripe 2024 Unit 3 and 4 Roof was Replaced in 2013 Concrete Replacement 2023 ($17,275)
  • Prime Visibility & Location – 144 Feet of Frontage along W Mitchell St (US-31), Petoskey’s main commercial corridor with strong daily tra?c counts
  • The Heart of Petoskey, MI - Nearly 1 MILLION Visitors Annually from Across the United States and the World www.petoskeyarea.com
  • Thriving Commercial Hub – Surrounded by national retailers, restaurants, medical o?ces, and local businesses generating steady foot tra?c
  • Upside in Rent Appreciation and Converting Leases from Gross to NNN

Contacts

broker

Encore Real Estate Investment Services

Location

Getting Around

  • Walk Score ®

    70/100 Somewhat Walkable
  • Bike Score ®

    62/100 Bikeable
Powered by Walk Score ®
  • City Petoskey, MI
  • Zip Code 49770

Points of Interest

  • Marathon

    0.09 miles

  • BP

    0.34 miles

  • Next Door Store

    0.34 miles

  • Petoskey Pacific Pride

    0.87 miles

  • JBJ Trucking

    1.80 miles

  • Meijer

    1.89 miles

  • Mobil

    2.51 miles

  • D&W Quick Stop

    2.63 miles

  • Citgo

    2.69 miles

  • Shell

    3.02 miles

  • Bear River Trail Sheridan Street Trailhead

    0.64 miles

  • Little Traverse Wheelway Trailhead

    4.61 miles

  • Krause Rd

    5.17 miles

  • Challenger lot

    7.12 miles

  • Tanton Family Reserve MTB Trailhead

    7.60 miles

  • Boyne City School Forest Trail

    8.08 miles

  • Boyne Forest Trails - East Trailhead Parking Lot

    8.08 miles

  • Boyne Forest Trails - West Trailhead Parking Lot

    8.64 miles

  • East Brutus Road Trailhead Parking

    9.10 miles

  • Arby's

    0.10 miles

  • Nagoya

    0.17 miles

  • Jet's Pizza

    0.19 miles

  • Subway

    0.21 miles

  • McDonald's

    0.26 miles

  • Big Boy

    0.29 miles

  • Mancino's

    0.29 miles

  • Wendy's

    0.31 miles

  • Villa Ristorante

    0.36 miles

  • Burger King

    0.38 miles

  • Grain Train Natural Foods Market

    0.50 miles

  • Gordon Food Service

    0.71 miles

  • Big Lots

    0.88 miles

  • Walmart Supercenter

    1.64 miles

  • ALDI

    1.82 miles

  • Meijer

    1.84 miles

  • Louie's Fresh Market

    2.28 miles

  • D&W Fresh Market

    2.72 miles

  • Oleson's

    4.26 miles

  • Harbor Springs IGA

    4.47 miles

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does The Reserve at Petoskey cost?

The space currently listed for sale at The Reserve at Petoskey asks for $750,000.

What is the total square footage of The Reserve at Petoskey?

The Reserve at Petoskey totals 6,496 square feet.

When was this property built?

The Reserve at Petoskey was built in 1970.

Looking for more in-depth information on this property?

Looking for more in-depth information on this property? Find property characteristics, ownership, tenant details, local market insights and more. Unlock data on CommercialEdge.

Contact Listing Broker
broker

Encore Real Estate Investment Services

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.