187 Utica Avenue

187 Utica Avenue, Crown Heights, NY 11213

Property Information

  • For Sale $2,495,000
  • Property Type Multi-Family
  • Property Size 6,000 SF
  • Units 6
  • Lot Size 2,520 SF
  • Date Updated Mar 13, 2026

Description

Free-Market Corner Mixed-Use Building

Sitting at the southwest corner of Utica Avenue and Park Place, this 3-story brick building offers over 100 feet of combined frontage. The property includes five free-market apartments and one ground-floor retail space, spanning approximately 6,000 gross square feet above cellar.

Renovated, Income-Producing Residential Units

Five renovated 2-bedroom box-style units averaging ~900 net SF each. Currently generating $212,400 in annual gross revenue, with clear upside to $291,000 as below-market units are brought to prevailing rents.

Immediate Value-Add & Owner/Operator Opportunity

The retail tenant vacates by March 1, 2026, allowing a new owner to lease the ground floor at market rate (~$5,000/month) or occupy it for their own business while collecting residential income. The vacant cellar adds further storage revenue potential of $1,500/month.

Favorable Tax Class 2A

Tax Class 2A status caps annual increases, providing predictable, cost-controlled ownership compared to comparable Class 4 commercial assets.

Prime Location — Walk Score 100

On a high-traffic retail corridor between Crown Heights and Bedford-Stuyvesant with exceptional transit access. The Utica Avenue subway station (A/C lines) is ~4 blocks away, with multiple bus lines directly in front.

Contacts

Stevie Haber

Haber Realty Group

Location

Located at 187 Utica Avenue, Crown Heights, NY 11213, this property is part of the Crown Heights neighborhood and Brooklyn market.

Contact Listing Broker
Stevie Haber

Haber Realty Group

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.