Hilldale Plaza

1566 East Sumner Street, Hartford, WI 53027

  • For Sale Unpriced
  • Property Type Retail
  • Property Size 61,782 SF
  • Lot Size 6.85 Acre
  • Property Tenancy Multi-Tenant
  • Year Built 1984
  • Year Renovated 1997
  • Date Updated May 15, 2025
Hilldale Plaza occupies a prominent corner on E. Sumner Street (Highway 60) in downtown Hartford—Washington County’s second‐largest trade node—offering direct visibility to 20,700 vehicles per day and seamless ingress/egress via dedicated signalized turns. The 6.85-acre lot is zoned General Commercial (C2), fully improved with municipal water, sewer, natural gas and high-capacity fiber on-site, and features 363 paved stalls (6.07 SP/1,000 SF) to accommodate robust visitor flow. Positioned just 1 mile east of the I-41 interchange, Hilldale benefits from both local retail synergy—adjacent to Walmart, Aldi and Festival Foods—and regional draw, tapping a five-mile population of 28,700 with a $105,800 average household income. Proximity to Hartford’s central business district ensures convenient access to banking, healthcare and government services, while planned residential growth to the north promises steadily expanding daytime and evening demand.Hilldale Plaza is a fully leased, 61,782 SF grocery-anchored retail center in Hartford, WI, featuring Piggly Wiggly (72.8 % of GLA) and four in-line tenants with a weighted average lease term exceeding four years. Delivering a 2025 As-Is NOI of $333,374 and below-market anchor rent poised for mark-to-market upside in 2029, the property boasts 6.07 stalls per 1,000 SF, strong visibility along Highway 60 (20,700 VPD) and an affluent five-mile trade area (28,700 population; $105,800 avg. household income). This asset offers stable cash flow with contractual escalations, limited grocery competition and significant value-add potential upon lease renewal.
Want more info on this listing?

Reach out to the broker for more info on lease terms and amenities

Highlights

  • Grocery-Anchored Stability: Piggly Wiggly represents 72.8 % of GLA at an in-place rent of $3.83 PSF, with mark-to-market upside upon renewal in 2029.
  • Full Occupancy & WALT: 100 % leased with a weighted average lease term > 4 years and built-in escalations across all five tenants.
  • Value-Add Potential: Below-market anchor rent and strong renewal leverage; opportunity to drive NOI at mark-to-market rates.
  • Prime Retail Corridor: 20,700 VPD on Highway 60; immediate proximity to Walmart, Aldi, Festival Foods, and easy access to I-41.
  • Affluent Trade Area: 5-mile population of 28,700 with average household income of $105,800 and limited direct grocery competition.

Contacts

broker

Mid-America Real Estate Group

Location

Getting Around

  • Walk Score ®

    47/100 Car-Dependent
  • Bike Score ®

    53/100 Bikeable
Powered by Walk Score ®
  • City Hartford, WI
  • Neighborhood Hartford
  • Zip Code 53027
  • Market Milwaukee

Points of Interest

  • Kwik Trip

    0.27 miles

  • Mobil

    0.90 miles

  • Shell

    1.45 miles

  • BP

    1.47 miles

  • Rapid Mart

    1.53 miles

  • Cenex

    2.40 miles

  • Casey's General Store

    2.66 miles

  • Parking Lot 8

    5.12 miles

  • Preserve Parking

    5.57 miles

  • Water Spirit Preserve

    6.88 miles

  • Richfield Park & Ride

    8.21 miles

  • Prairie

    8.98 miles

  • East Woodland

    9.07 miles

  • North Woodland

    9.09 miles

  • Lower Level

    9.78 miles

  • Paradise Drive Park & Ride

    9.83 miles

  • Upper Level

    9.84 miles

  • Evergreen Chinese Buffet

    0.06 miles

  • Sal's Pizza

    0.07 miles

  • Culver's

    0.08 miles

  • Qdoba

    0.09 miles

  • Jimmy John's

    0.10 miles

  • Taco Bell

    0.11 miles

  • Dunkin'

    0.15 miles

  • Papa Murphy's

    0.16 miles

  • McDonald's

    0.18 miles

  • Subway

    0.18 miles

  • Piggly Wiggly

    0.01 miles

  • ALDI

    0.18 miles

  • Walmart Supercenter

    2.56 miles

  • Back to the Best

    7.40 miles

  • Meijer

    9.83 miles

  • Marshalls

    9.93 miles

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does Hilldale Plaza cost?

The sale price for Hilldale Plaza is available upon request. Contact the listing broker for more information.

What is the total square footage of Hilldale Plaza?

Hilldale Plaza totals 61,782 square feet.

When was this property built?

Hilldale Plaza was built in 1984.

Looking for more in-depth information on this property?

Looking for more in-depth information on this property? Find property characteristics, ownership, tenant details, local market insights and more. Unlock data on CommercialEdge.

Contact Listing Broker
broker

Mid-America Real Estate Group

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.