1164 Connecticut St

1164 Connecticut Street, Gary, IN 46407

Property Information

  • For Sale Contact for pricing
  • Property Type Multi-Family
  • Property Size 13,400 SF
  • Units 19
  • Lot Size 0.23 Acre
  • Year Built 1927
  • Year Renovated 2025
  • Date Updated May 26, 2026

Description

Situated just off Broadway in Gary, IN, the property is within walking distance to retail, grocery, and entertainment amenities and minutes from surrounding schools and nearby cities.The investment opportunity offers a clear value-add strategy through renovating the remaining unrenovated units, completing full gut rehabs of the two vacant units, and improving operations through modern leasing, marketing, and maintenance systems. The property consists of two adjacent buildings located at 1164 and 1170 Connecticut St. in Gary, Indiana, within walking distance to retail, grocery, and entertainment and just minutes from surrounding schools and nearby cities. Originally built in 1927 and updated over time, the buildings feature multiple entrances, ample street parking, and access to an adjacent vacant lot used for tenant parking. Unit interiors include hardwood floors, wood trim, updated kitchens in select units, and strong natural light throughout. Tenants separately pay cooking gas and electric through NIPSCO, while ownership covers heat, common area electric, and water, creating potential upside through future RUBs implementation. Additional upside exists through basement renovations to bring tenant storage and on-site laundry online. Most units have already received light renovations including updated finishes, flooring, cabinets, and appliances. Major capital improvements include complete tear-off roof replacements in 2021 and new boiler systems installed in 2022. Positioned just off Broadway, Gary's main north-south corridor, the asset stands to benefit from ongoing redevelopment and investment throughout the area.

Highlights

  • Basement renovation opportunity for tenant storage and on-site laundry
  • Benefits from ongoing redevelopment and investment in the area
  • Clear value-add strategy through renovating remaining unrenovated units
  • Complete full gut rehabs of two vacant units
  • Complete tear-off roof replacements in 2021
  • Hardwood floors, wood trim, updated kitchens in select units
  • Improve operations through modern leasing, marketing, and maintenance systems
  • Most units already received light renovations
  • Multiple entrances and ample street parking
  • New boiler systems installed in 2022
  • Positioned just off Broadway, Gary's main north-south corridor
  • Potential upside through future RUBs implementation
  • Two adjacent buildings at 1164 and 1170 Connecticut St.
  • Within walking distance to retail, grocery, and entertainment

Contacts

Kyle Sissell

Kiser Group

Location

Located at 1164 Connecticut Street, Gary, IN 46407, this property is part of the Midtown Gary neighborhood and Chicago market.

Contact Listing Broker
Kyle Sissell

Kiser Group

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.