- For Sale $548,000
- Property Type Retail
- Lot Size 33,976 SF
- Date Updated Aug 10, 2026
Description
MOTIVATED SELLER - Beautifully restored 1900 Victorian paired with a fully renovated, detached 2-bedroom apartment--a rare Catskills offering that seamlessly blends historic elegance, modern comfort, and exceptional income potential set on 2 parcels of beautiful land to equal 0.78 acres. Whether youre searching for a full-time residence, a weekend retreat, multigenerational living, or a property where rental income can help offset your mortgage, this remarkable property offers endless possibilities.The 1,848-square-foot Victorian showcases original woodwork, soaring ceilings, a welcoming front porch, and timeless architectural details, while the beautifully renovated 809-square-foot apartment above the detached garage provides privacy and comfort for guests, extended family, or a rental potential.Surrounded by mountain views and a year-round stream, this unique property also offers limited commercial zoning, creating even greater flexibility for future use. Ideally located just minutes from Belleayre Mountain, hiking, skiing, fishing, and the many attractions of the Catskills, it combines natural beauty with unmatched versatility.A rare opportunity to own a distinctive Catskills property where historic character, modern convenience, and income-producing potential come together in one exceptional offering.Additional Facts: Windows in the main house and apartment are under 5 years as well as the siding and gutters to the main house....Roofs 10 years old....200 amp in main house and 200 amp in garage and apartment - Outside electric is new....Well pump with pressure (bladder) one year old....Septic 15 years old with leach field.... ....1/2 bath in 809 SF garage.COME SEE ALL THIS PROPERTY HAS TO OFFER!!
Highlights
- Cooling: Window A/C
- Heating Type: Other
- Onteora Central School District
- Sewer: Septic
- Water: Well
False
Contacts
Susan Lennon
Coldwell Banker Timberland Properties
Location
Located at 26 FIRE HOUSE ROAD, Big Indian, NY 12410, this property is part of the Big Indian neighborhood and White Plains market.
Contact Listing Broker
Susan Lennon
Coldwell Banker Timberland Properties