Mahoning Auto Shop

5202 Mahoning Avenue, Youngstown, OH 44515

Property Information

  • For Sale $899,000
  • Property Type Retail - Street Retail
  • Property Size 1,982 SF
  • Units 1
  • Lot Size 0.62 Acre
  • Date Updated Sep 2, 2026

Description

5202 Mahoning Avenue is strategically located at the highly visible corner of Mahoning Avenue and SR 11 in Youngstown, Ohio, providing excellent exposure and convenient accessibility for customers, employees, and commercial users. The property benefits from its position along a prominent commercial corridor with strong connectivity to SR 11 and surrounding major roadways, providing convenient access throughout the Youngstown/Austintown trade area. The location is surrounded by a mix of retail, automotive, service businesses, restaurants, and other commercial uses, creating an established commercial environment. Its signalized/high-visibility corner positioning and existing commercial use make the site particularly attractive for an automotive operator, owner-user, retail business, or investor seeking a strategically positioned property with future redevelopment potential. The property's location along Mahoning Avenue and its proximity to SR 11 provide an opportunity to capture both local traffic and regional commuters, supporting continued commercial use and enhancing the site's potential for future retail redevelopment, subject to applicable zoning and municipal approvColdwell Banker Commercial Realty is pleased to announce that Strategically positioned at the corner of SR 11 and Mahoning Avenue, 5202 Mahoning Avenue presents an excellent opportunity for an owner-user, automotive operator, investor, or developer seeking a highly visible commercial location in the Youngstown/Austintown market. The property features an approximately 1,982-square-foot commercial building currently configured as a 4-bay auto repair facility, with an office area and customer waiting area. The property is reportedly zoned B-2, providing a commercial setting suitable for a range of potential business and redevelopment concepts, subject to applicable zoning and municipal approvals. Public property records also identify the site as a 1,982 SF retail/auto-shop property with B-2 zoning. The corner location at SR 11 and Mahoning Avenue provides strong visibility and convenient access, making the site attractive for continued automotive use or repositioning for another retail or service-oriented use. Redevelopment Potential Beyond its existing use, the property offers redevelopment potential for retail or other commercial applications. Its prominent corner positioning and commercial zoning create an opportunity for an investor or developer to explore a future redevelopment concept, subject to zoning, site-plan, access, parking, and municipal approvals. Flexible Acquisition Options The opportunity may be structured to accommodate different investment strategies: Purchase the real estate and continue operating the existing auto repair facility. Acquire the property for redevelopment and reposition the site for a new retail or commercial use. Purchase the existing automotive business while ground leasing the underlying land, providing an alternative structure for an operator seeking to control the business without acquiring the real estate. Owner-user opportunity for an automotive, service, or retail operator seeking a highly visible location. All zoning, permitted uses, redevelopment concepts, and development potential should be independently verified with the applicable municipality and authorities having jurisdiction.

Highlights

  • ±1,982 SF building
  • 4 automotive service bays
  • B-2 commercial zoning
  • Corner location at SR 11 & Mahoning Avenue
  • Existing auto repair use
  • Existing office and customer waiting area
  • Flexible purchase and ground-lease structure available
  • Retail/commercial redevelopment potential
  • Suitable for owner-user, investor, automotive operator, or developer

Contacts

Location

Located at 5202 Mahoning Avenue, Youngstown, OH 44515, this property is part of the Heather Hills neighborhood and Youngstown market.

Contact Listing Broker
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.