NYAH

823 Fleming Street, Key West, FL 33040

  • For Sale $19,550,000
  • Property Type Other
  • Property Size 14,161 SF
  • Units 35
  • Lot Size 0.63 Acre
  • Year Built 1892
  • Date Updated Sep 3, 2025
Discover the allure of Key West, FL, a vibrant city with a rich history and a unique blend of laid-back island vibes and bustling Island activity. The area surrounding the location is home to renowned attractions like the historic Key West Historic Seaport, where the iconic Mallory Square offers a nightly sunset celebration, and the lively Duval Street, lined with eclectic shops, art galleries, and acclaimed restaurants. Investors in search of a guesthouse will find a dynamic environment with an ideal balance of work and play, all within close proximity to the property. Enjoy a prime location where business opportunities seamlessly intertwine with the island's irresistible charm.Located on the northside of Old Town only two blocks from the historic Key West Port, NYAH is walking distance from the main strip of bars and restaurants on Duval and proximate to historical landmarks such as the Southernmost Point, Ernest Hemingway Home, Key West Butterfly Conservatory, and Mallory Square. The Property is designed for hosting group travelers offering both private and shared guestrooms. Private Rooms can accommodate groups of up to six people and each guest is provided their own bed, locker, and set of towels. Guestroom amenities include en-suite bathrooms, private lockers, and personal charging docks. Home to three outdoor pools, NYAH is in possession of a bar license and serves drinks from the front desk. NYAH also features an office space which can be converted into a 3-bedroom transient unit. As the Property holds 36 transient licenses, no additional ROGO is needed.
Want more info on this listing?

Reach out to the broker for more info on lease terms and amenities

Contacts

broker
Team Gardner-Langley

Keys Real Estate | Knight & Gardner Realty

Location

Getting Around

  • Walk Score ®

    93/100 Walker's Paradise
  • Transit Score ®

    28/100 Some Transit
  • Bike Score ®

    100/100 Biker's Paradise
Powered by Walk Score ®
  • City Key West, FL
  • Neighborhood Historic Seaport
  • Zip Code 33040

Points of Interest

  • Chevron

    0.49 miles

  • Citgo

    0.51 miles

  • Circle K

    0.93 miles

  • Shell

    0.97 miles

  • Owen's Oco-Pep

    1.13 miles

  • Electrify America

    2.20 miles

  • Mobil

    2.27 miles

  • Old Town Garage

    0.16 miles

  • 201 Front Street Garage

    0.53 miles

  • Key West Tropical Forest & Botanical Garden

    3.29 miles

  • Oceans Edge Resort & Marina Parking

    4.47 miles

  • NYAH Key West Hotel

    0.02 miles

  • Island City House Hotel

    0.05 miles

  • Westwinds Inn Key West

    0.08 miles

  • Seaport Inn

    0.10 miles

  • Fitch Lodge - Key West Historic Inns

    0.20 miles

  • Fitch Lodge

    0.21 miles

  • Marquesa Hotel

    0.22 miles

  • Frances Street Bottle Inn

    0.23 miles

  • The Key West Harbor Inn 1

    0.24 miles

  • The Artist House

    0.25 miles

  • Mangia Mangia Pizza Cafe

    0.12 miles

  • Bien Caribbean-Latino Restaurant

    0.14 miles

  • Harpoon Harry's

    0.15 miles

  • Pepe’s

    0.15 miles

  • Cuban Coffee Queen

    0.20 miles

  • Cafe Sole

    0.22 miles

  • Waterfront Brewery

    0.23 miles

  • Half Shell Raw Bar

    0.23 miles

  • Schooner Wharf Bar

    0.25 miles

  • Sarabeth's Kitchen

    0.26 miles

  • Mary Immaculate Star of the Sea School

    0.50 miles

  • Montessori Children's School

    0.68 miles

  • Reynolds School

    0.72 miles

  • Horace O'Bryant Middle School

    0.77 miles

  • Mary Sands Alternative School

    0.83 miles

  • Key West High School

    1.43 miles

  • Poinciana Elementary School

    2.11 miles

  • Sigsbee Charter Elementary School

    2.13 miles

  • SFUWO School

    2.41 miles

  • Gerald Adams Elementary School

    3.68 miles

  • Inez Martin (United Methodist Wesley House) Child Development Center

    0.57 miles

  • Lighthouse Christian Academy

    3.93 miles

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does NYAH cost?

The space currently listed for sale at NYAH asks for $19,550,000.

What is the total square footage of NYAH?

NYAH totals 14,161 square feet.

When was this property built?

NYAH was built in 1892.

Looking for more in-depth information on this property?

Looking for more in-depth information on this property? Find property characteristics, ownership, tenant details, local market insights and more. Unlock data on CommercialEdge.

Contact Listing Broker
broker
Team Gardner-Langley

Keys Real Estate | Knight & Gardner Realty

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.