5363 & 5365 Main Street

5363 & 5365 Main Street, Williamsville, NY 14221

Property Information

  • For Lease $21.00/SF/YR
  • Property Type Retail - Street Retail
  • Property Size 8,500 SF
  • Units 3
  • Lot Size 0.86 Acre
  • Parking Spaces Avail. 40
  • Property Tenancy Multi-Tenant
  • Year Built 1957
  • Year Renovated 2016
  • Date Updated Jun 1, 2026

Description

Former Monro Muffler and adjoining 5363 Main. Available nowOpen now at 5363 Main are an exciting Yemeni coffee franchise, Qamaria Cafe, in the 2,400 sf area immediately west of AltYou, and Rustic Buffalo, an established local artisan general store in the 1,263 sf free standing building closer to Main Street. Available now is: (1.) at 5363 Main, AltYou, a gym of about 1,550 sf, has a term to October 31, 2025 and will be vacating. The rent for this space would be $21 per sf NNN, in its current condition, with 3% base rent increases per year. (2.) a ground lease or build-to-suit of up to 2,900 sf on the south/rear of 5365 Main. Attached is a sketch showing how a small building could be placed on the parcel. The former Monro Muffler of about 2,900 sf at 5365 Main is under lease subject to construction approval contingencies. The properties are just west of South Long Street and immediately north of the great new Village of Williamsville recreation park. The site is just five blocks east of the I-290/Main access and exit.

2 Spaces Available

5363 Main Street

Space Type

Freestanding

Lease Rate

$21.00/SF/YR

Total Space

1,550 SF

Floor

1

Divisible Space

1,550 - 1,550 SF

Available Date

Immediate

Lease Type

NNN

Renewal Option

Yes

Sublease

No

The related ownership of 5363 Main owns 5365 Main, the former Monro Muffler property, adjoining immediately to the east and is ready to entertain leases. The building is about 67.35' x 43.39', or 2,922 sf.

5365 Main St

Space Type

Freestanding

Lease Rate

$21.00/SF/YR

Total Space

2,922 SF

Divisible Space

2,922 - 2,922 SF

Available Date

Immediate

Lease Type

NNN

Renewal Option

Yes

Sublease

No

Contacts

Stephen Hunt

HUNT Commercial

Location

Located at 5363 & 5365 Main Street, Williamsville, NY 14221, this property is part of the Williamsville neighborhood and Buffalo market.

Contact Listing Broker
Stephen Hunt

HUNT Commercial

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.